Claim.no.1EMIAJ

If mortgage market fears manifest, the mortgage market cracks in the back half of 2028, and the S&P 500 drawdown would ultimately rival the GFC's 57% peak-to-trough, bringing the S&P to ~3500.

Pessimistic
Share

Original Quote

If these fears manifest, the mortgage market cracks in the back half of this year. In that scenario, we'd expect the current drawdown in equities to ultimately rival that of the GFC (57% peak-to-trough). This would bring the S&P500 to ~3500 - levels we haven't seen since the month before the ChatGPT moment in November 2022.

Outlook

Pessimistic

A 57% equity drawdown and mortgage market crisis would represent catastrophic wealth destruction and financial system stress.

Timeframe
2028Explicit
Confidence
conditional/possible

Explicitly conditional on whether mortgage market fears materialize, implying uncertain but possible confidence.

Potential Data Sources for Validation

S&P 500 price data; mortgage delinquency rates from Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and MBA; home price indices from Zillow/Case-Shiller.

About the Author

James van Geelen

Citrini is the pseudonymous founder of Citrinitas Capital Management Inc. and the author of Citrini Research, a top finance Substack specializing in thematic equity investing and global macro trading, known for early calls on AI and GLP-1 investments.

Author Perspective

Across 17 tracked claims, James van Geelen skews pessimistic.

0% optimistic100% pessimistic
published Mar 6, 2026Pessimistic